Skip to content

Schnabel argues for policy flexibility and a demand-led ECB liquidity framework

In personal reflections published by the ECB, Isabel Schnabel argued for flexible monetary tools and a balance sheet no larger than necessary. She outlined a demand-led approach to supplying banks with liquidity.

Latest data

Isabel Schnabel said in a speech published by the European Central Bank on 5 November 2026 that monetary policy should preserve flexibility and operate with a balance sheet no larger than necessary. Presenting her remarks as personal reflections, she argued that banks’ demand should determine the marginal provision of central bank liquidity.

Schnabel favoured policy rates as an agile instrument, contrasting their meeting-by-meeting adjustability with asset purchases that continue providing accommodation after buying ends. She nevertheless retained a role for purchases in stabilising illiquid markets and countering deflationary pressures at the effective lower bound. Separating market-stabilisation tools from instruments setting the policy stance could preserve flexibility, she said.

On inflation, Schnabel argued that the projected price path, rather than a simple distinction between supply and demand shocks, should guide policy. She said medium- to longer-term consumer inflation expectations had risen and moved away from the ECB’s 2% target following the latest energy shock. These assessments were part of her argument, not a new committee decision.

Liquidity provision and market resilience

Schnabel said the ECB was winding down its asset purchase programme and pandemic emergency purchase programme portfolios because their monetary policy motivation no longer existed. In principle, she said, those holdings could fall to zero unless a return to the effective lower bound made renewed purchases necessary for price stability.

Under the operational framework she described, banks can request liquidity weekly at a fixed rate against a broad collateral set. Her preferred transition would start with structural longer-term refinancing operations while legacy portfolios still supplied substantial liquidity. A structural securities portfolio would follow once those holdings had run off sufficiently; this sequence was explicitly her reading of the framework.

The economic significance is a potential shift towards more market-based liquidity management, rather than simply a smaller central bank balance sheet. If banks seek private funding before using ECB facilities, private-market activity could regain space. Demand-led refinancing could still accommodate liquidity needs as legacy portfolios shrink. However, Schnabel’s warning about leveraged non-bank investors qualifies that benefit: falling collateral values or tighter funding can force position unwinds and destabilise sovereign bond markets. A leaner framework would therefore still need effective liquidity backstops and oversight, rather than treating reduced reserves alone as evidence of greater resilience.

Article information

This article draws on the cited sources and relevant public material. It may include summaries, translations or supporting analysis and does not replace the full announcement, regulatory document or dataset. Check facts, definitions, statistical methods and effective conditions against the original source, particularly where a translation differs.

Companies, broker brands and legal entities must be distinguished. A licence, permission or announcement concerning one entity should not automatically be applied to related brands, other entities, products or jurisdictions. Reporting and commentary do not constitute investment advice, trading recommendations or assurances of safety, compliance or suitability.

Information is time-sensitive: announcements, register entries and data may be updated or revised. The publication and update dates on this page refer to this website’s article record and may differ from the event or original release date. Before acting, check current source material, the applicable jurisdiction and your actual contracting entity.